Fraudster turned fraudbuster turned pastor turns fraudster again: Pleads guilty to stealing from his church

Barry Minkow, pastor of San Diego Community Bible Church (SDCBC) pled guilty to embezzling $3 million from his church. The U.S. Attorney for Southern District of California announced the plea agreement on 1-22-14. You can see the press release here.

Pr. Minkow first went to prison as the mastermind of the ZZZZ Best fraud which collapsed back in 1987. He served under 8 years of a 25 year sentence.

After release he worked at a church in the LA area then became pastor at SDCBC. He started a for-profit company that researched and publicized frauds.

In 2011, he pled guilty to insider trading for reportedly shorting a stock before denouncing the company for alleged irregularities. He drew a five-year sentence for that felony.

That brings us to this week. In the press release announcing a plea agreement, the US AG says

…Minkow admitted to a litany of improper conduct, including opening unauthorized bank accounts on behalf of the SDCBC, forging signatures on SDCBC checks, using funds drawn on legitimate church accounts for his personal benefit, and charging unauthorized personal expenses on church credit cards. In addition, Minkow confessed to diverting SDCBC member donations for his own benefit and embezzling money intended as church donations. In all, Minkow admitted purloining – and concealing from the IRS – at least $3 million from SDCBC’s parishioners and lenders. As described in court documents, Minkow’s conduct continued for over a decade.

 “Over a decade” would put this from somewhere around 2011 back to around 2001. That would be something in the range of 4 years after becoming pastor of SDCBC.

Looks like there are a lot of things here that leaders of churches and nonprofits can learn from.  Things like internal control, separation of duties, authority given to senior pastor, board oversight, time needed to recover from a moral failure. All stuff that is extremely pertinent to leaders in the NPO community.

I’ll see what I can find.

Here’s a few articles out of many articles visible today, if you want a few more details:

Update:  Press release says the IRS Criminal Investigation Division was involved. The press release says the plea agreement admitted to $89K of unreported income. Oops. That means there will soon be a bill in the mail for unpaid taxes.

2 Responses to Fraudster turned fraudbuster turned pastor turns fraudster again: Pleads guilty to stealing from his church

  1. Jim,

    Thanks so much for this post. I hadn’t heard.

    There is no cure for pschopathy, murderous or financial. Once a fraudster, always a fraudster. The moral of this story is never to trust a fraudster.

    Dave

  2. Jim Ulvog says:

    Hi Dave:

    I believe it is possible to restore someone to leadership. However, it would take a long time for lots of mentoring, counseling, and observing. Two years from getting out of jail to leading a church? That doesn’t seem to be long enough by a long shot.

    Thanks for taking time to comment.

    Jim

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: